#E5D1A1 · #ECC4E9
Four independent scores (read the one that fits your goal): Readability 0/100 (fail) · Harmony 65/100 (triadic (soft)) · Distinguishable 49/100 (somewhat similar) · Match 2/100 (different). There is no single “good/bad” — a pair can clash for text yet be great for an outfit.
Caramel and Thistle are very different (ΔE 44). They have distinctly different hues (98° apart) and their lightness is similar, so they read as two same-weight colours.
Caramel text on Thistle: 1.02:1 (Fail); Thistle text on Caramel: 1.02:1 (Fail). Neither meets AA at body size — nudging one color to #69572B clears it.
Triadic (soft) — workable but not a textbook harmony (harmony 65/100). This is about how they look together (clothing, interiors, branding), independent of text contrast.
Not at body size — the best direction is only 1.0:1, below the 4.5:1 minimum. Nudging one colour to #69572B clears AA.
Their CIE76 ΔE is about 44 — very different.
clearly different colours (ΔE 44).
Explore each color: Caramel #E5D1A1 · Thistle #ECC4E9 · Shades: Caramel shades · Thistle shades · Contrast checker →